Showing posts with label Apple. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Apple. Show all posts

Monday, July 19, 2010

Why a Google-world gives me comfort...

"Having heard the strategy for Android based phones first hand, I can tell you why this is a very flawed perspective. The telecom analyst, Jack Gold's perspective comes close to the company philosophy. As they did with many of their web products, this is just a beta launch. You should see some great products coming out close '10 Christmas shopping season. "

Cost is about the carrier

Industry analyst Jack Gold of J. Gold Associates agreed that potential customers would do well to think about the long-term costs before snapping up the latest and greatest mobile device.

"What customers and users need to be thinking about is that the service plan cost is all about the carrier, not the device," Gold said

Google's revenue model is not the same as that of Apple. The models are poles apart.

Apple extorts 30% or more of your monthly bill's value from the carrier - it's a fixed sum mostly and may also feature an ADDITIONAL variable revenue stream. You never get to see that even though you've paid a massive premium for the phone. Lock-in periods ensure that they recover the cost of the phone entirely and then some more. What the networks hate even more is that while Apple uses the phones which the networks bleed over for selling content over the itunes platform they never get to see that revenue. All they get is the passthrough cost of using the network bandwidth - which is a commodity now - and may soon be free. And given that most iphones are wifi ready and with wifi being ubiquitous even their bandwidth usage seems to be dropping. So for a network, selling iphones is increasingly a not-so-necessary evil. Every network is rooting for an iphone killer - which is a matter of time.

Now for google's model. Google has made it's millions riding the ad-funded content route. They make advertisers pay top-dollar to reach google customers. Google ostensibly reaches many many more people than apple's products do - including those who use apple's products. For google every new venture is an experiment towards perfecting their $30+billion ad-revenue model. They have no interest whatsoever in making money from hardware. And hardware too is becoming a commodity - any detractors might just want to observe the number of and sophistication (which is a term that conjures up different meanings for each person) of the smaller brands in the market. Yes, it's important for google to get a wider footing in the mobile market with a GREAT device which, like Sachin rightly pointed out, is probably a few months away. The Droid's mew avataar is expected anytime soon. As is a slew of WinMo7 phones. Rumours have it that Sony is about to cave in to the Android OS. LG's on the bandwagon, Samsung is joining in. Nokia will cave in eventually when Symbian crumbles. (3% of the mobile phones - smartphones; sold globally account for 35% of the profit. These figures are expected to read 10% and 55% in 2012. Nokia has close to zero% share of that market). Google is testing the market with phone after phone - all using the Android platform, which arguably, is FAR superior to the iphone's OS. And google may one day give a ad-supported ad-sponsored phone away for free (or almost), while agreeing to share the spoils of the ad-revenue with the operator and the device manufacturer. It's a thought, nothing's impossible.

Content, is another ball-game altogether. Admittedly google is struggling to aggregate content which users would like to pay for. Apps, for one, music and e-commerce applications come next. The rest are small-potatoes. Apple still leads the pack because of the itunes store. However we all know that with content being platform agnostic, people are finding alternate routes to sate their hunger for content. Google's now beginning to sell movies, music and serial episodes on YouTube - this began a few weeks ago. YouTube has more visitors than itunes will ever have. Major label and studio owners are quite keen on harnessing the strength of YouTube and one would want to watch that space keenly. What's more, Google is working with TV manufacturers and processor manufacturers to sell TV sets that're always-on, cloud computing devices. Winter 2010 may see the first such TV's hit the shelves. Then google has a shot at the global TV ad market!

As for developer delight - well Apple makes you jump hoops before agreeing to have your app featured on itunes. I guess Sandeep would be able to shed more light on this bit.

I'd still bet on a Google-world. The cloud is real and they're the cloud - or most of it, at least :-)

Now all I hope is that they don't play "net-neutrality surrender-monkey" and disappoint us all. Google, please don't do that, we wouldn't want to love you any less.

Cheers!

Sunday, July 18, 2010

Is Apple mortal after all?

One of the enduring mysteries of medieval France revolves around whether the French queen, Marie Antoinette, ever actually utter the phrase, "Let them eat cake"? Another enduring mystery of our times seems to revolve around whether the Czar of the technology design world Steve Jobs, famously retorted to a customer "either hold the phone a different way or buy a case!"

Apple, after long denying the "Antennagate" phenomenon finally, bowed to public pressure applied by legions of fans who usually explain away every Apple design flaw gratefully as the "price of genius" and/or "the price of being given the opportunity of owning an Apple product".

That it took no less than a visibly weakened Steve Jobs to address public and admit that he was "stunned and upset and embarrassed" to learn about the iPhone's design flaw that in his words "is not unique to the iPhone4" and in the same breath claim that "this has been blown so out of proportion that it's incredible", seems to bely the triviality of the issue. Mr. Jobs, you wouldn't have handed out $29 x 3 million worth of cases ($87,000,000 + transaction costs) if you sincerely believed that "we're not feeling right now that we have a giant problem we need to fix". You're an incredibly smart businessman, probably the brightest ever, so we don't quite believe you when you say it's a "small matter" and you "aren't worried" about it.

Apple also claims that the main problem is actually with the software on board the phone that shows a stronger signal when the reception is not actually that strong. Does the software do this by itself? Or was it designed to show a signal stronger than the actual signal reception capability of the phone? That we'll never know. Signal strength is a critical USP for many a phone manufacturer. Yes, maybe all phone manufacturers resort to dialing up 'signal strength' and then maybe none of them do that. The point is Apple wasn't "that sort of a company" to start with. A dialed up signal display isn't an inadvertent flaw, Mr. Jobs - and maybe it was done knowing well that the phone's new antenna design wasn't performing quite as well as Apple expected it to? Because now that you mentioned it, we (commoners) can't help but think that way.

The crux of the matter is that like Toyota, Apple took its time to admit to the presence of a problem or let's say admit to a consumer perception of a problem when none may have existed (or if it did exist it didn't warrant a global media frenzy). The fallout from this episode is that Apple now seems to be very mortal after all. It's products have shortcomings and defects (serious or not) which its legions of die-hard fans and new-found fans are finally coming to admit - in public. Is this a sign that Apple's customer base has grown far beyond the numbers that qualify as a "cult"? Has the Apple fan-base been contaminated by "ordinary mortals" drawn to its admittedly fashionable and oh-so-sexy persona? Does this new legion of not-so-forgiving consumers/fans spell further trouble for Apple? Was Apple meant to cater to these "masses"?

Apple's success lies in making and marketing fabulously designed products that perform almost as admirably or not as another functional brand in the market, to a customer base that can well afford the equally fabulous price-premium Apple demands as a membership to an elitist club that is second to none. Few humans can deny that an Apple product does not stir desire in them. Suddenly more than a few humans could afford to join 'the club' - Apple's ambitions made it so. The problem - for Apple, is that these new-kids-on-the-block aren't as price insensitive as the 'fanboys' are and neither are they as forgiving of "minor issues common to all phones that have been blown so out of proportion". This a new breed of consumer, a breed VERY different from the one that made Apple a boutique technology player.

Apple must carefully consider its ambitions and and match its own attitude and delivery with the expectations of the new consumers their ambition will attract. The consumers that made Apple the uber-successful company it is today are the "common lot" and not the 'fanboys'. Mr. Jobs and his company would do well to spend more time understanding the inhabitants of this new territory of the market they have occupied and possibly change either their approach to product design and/or quality management, or their approach to tackling problems when they crop-up. Like Toyota did, Apple must not believe it is immortal, even if they say they aren't, because when they say "we aren't perfect" they should sound like they mean what they're saying and are saying what they mean.